Best Sandwich Makers – Reviews & Buying Guides

Best Sandwich Makers – Reviews & Buying Guides

One of life’s simple pleasure is a warm toasted sandwich overloaded with cheese, ham, or veggies. This is the reason why a sandwich maker is everybody’s favorite appliance in the morning. Perfectly paired up with a coffee machine, it’s the excellent way to fuel up and jumpstart the day.

Sandwich makers are small appliances that add variety in your diet. From simple cheese grilled sandwiches to French toast to pocket-style sandwiches, you can be as creative as you can.

To help you find the best sandwich maker, we evaluated 6 recommended sandwich makers for you.

6 Recommended Sandwich Makers in 2019

After thorough research and evaluation, we have come up with six bestselling sandwich makers in 2019. If you are looking for a multifunctional sandwich maker, gourmet sandwich maker, basic sandwich press, or for multiple sandwiches, this list got it all covered.

So without further ado here is the best sandwich makers in the market right now:

NameGrill PlateWattageWarranty
Breville BSG520XL Panini Duo PressNon-detachable1,5001-Year
Cuisinart WM-SW2N Dual-Sandwich GrillNon-detachable1,5003-Year
Aicok Sandwich MakerDetachable8002- Year
Proctor Silex 25408Y Sandwich ToasterNon-detachable7001-Year
Hamilton Beach 25490 Sandwich MakerDetachable6005-Year
Kealive Sandwich MakerNon-detachable7503- Year

1. Breville BSG520XL Panini Duo Press

Breville BSG520XL

Brevile has earned the homeowners’ trust for decades. BSG520XL is another quality product that inherits the brand’s professional quality at a reasonable price.

It is made of non-stick Quantanium plates with a flat bottom for fast cooking and hinged plate on the other side for a grilled mark. Powered by 1500-watt electric coils, it heats up in no time and cooks your sandwich in minutes.

One of the unique features of Breville BSG520XL is the floating hinge with four adjustable height settings. Depending on the thickness of your sandwich, you can maintain an even pressure to cook all sides evenly. Combined with stainless steel material and scratch-resistant surface, it provides long-lasting dependability and quality.

One bonus feature of Breville BSG520XL is the anti-slip base that keeps it in place. It also comes with a cord wrap for mess-free storage and user manual with recipes for meal ideas. A one-year warranty backs all of these qualities.

Pros
  • Floating hinge to cook all sides evenly
  • Nonstick, scratch-proof Quantanium grill plates
  • Creates a beautifully grilled mark on sandwiches
  • 1500-watt heating mechanism for fast cooking
  • Non-skid foot to keep it in place while cooking or in storage
Cons
  • Does not have on/off button
  • No grease collector

2. Cuisinart WM-SW2N Dual-Sandwich Grill

Cuisinart WM-SW2N Dual-Sandwich

If you’re looking for an inexpensive sandwich maker with straightforward function, the Cuisinart dual-sandwich nonstick grill is the right choice. It is easy to use intended for users who don’t want too much fuss. The diagonal indentation cuts the sandwich in half for you, and it can prepare up to two sandwiches at a time.

When the grilling is done, the nonstick plates release the toasts quickly without any mess. If you wish to cook waffles, pancakes, and omelet, you can do so by adding a little oil onto the plates. Once plugged in, a red light turns on which indicate that the device is heating up. When it goes green, the grill is ready for use.

The Cuisinart WM-SW2N Sandwich Nonstick Electric Grill does not require professional or technical skills. It doesn’t have rotating plates, touchscreen panel, or any other advanced features. Place the bread, layer with cheese, meat, or vegetables, and top with another piece of bread. Close and secure the lid while it grills the sandwich. With very minimal effort and time, you can have hot sandwiches on busy days.

Pros
  • Diagonal indentation cuts the sandwich in half
  • Indicator lights for heat up and ready-for-use
  • Can also cook batters and omelet
  • Deep grill plates for additional ingredients
Cons
  • Electrical wire cover may fall off

3. Aicok 3 in 1 Sandwich Maker

Aicok 3 in 1 Sandwich Maker

If you are willing to spend more for versatility, the Aicok Sandwich Maker is for you. It has three detachable non-stick coated plates, each of which can be used for making sandwiches and waffles, and cooking meats. It is a multi plate toast maker powered by 800-watt electric coils that prepare the food in as fast as three minutes.

Each plate has a modern design – one for the sandwich with diagonal indentation, one for the waffles and omelet, and another one for cooking thin slices of meat. Another advantage of Aicok Sandwich Maker is its compact dimensions making it easy to transport and store horizontally or vertically in limited spaces.

One unique feature is the temperature control with indicator light. The stainless steel surface protects the user from the internal heat to prevent burning. It also comes with a thermostat that automatically shuts down the device at maximum temperature to avoid burning and fire. Aside from multifunctionality, the Aicok Sandwich Maker ensures safety.

Pros
  • Comes with lid closure to prevent mess and batter drips
  • Heat-protected surface and handle
  • Multi plated appliance for more functionality
  • Portable and saves space
  • Controllable temperature
Cons
  • Might not be hot enough to cook many ingredients

4. Proctor Silex 25408Y Toaster

Proctor Silex Sandwich Toaster

The first thing that one will notice about the Proctor Silex 25408Y Sandwich Toaster is its elegant white design. It is just another basic toaster, but with the excellent quality that gives value to money. It quickly heats up and makes hot sandwiches in minutes. Similar to the Cuisinart WM-SW2N Electric Grill, it has an integrated indentation that cuts the sandwich in half.

The indicator lights let you know when the sandwich maker is on and when it is ready for cooking. When available, you arrange your sandwich on the grill plates, close the lid, and wait for a few minutes. When done, you will have a perfectly toasted sandwich with finished edges. The browning effect depends on how long you put the sandwich inside the device.

Hamilton Beach 25408Y is also space-friendly. It has a small size similar to the Cuisinart WM-SW2N Grill, but with a lock handle so you can place it upright inside any storage spaces. And since the plates are nonstick, they are easy to clean.

Pros
  • Can fit and cut two sandwiches at a time
  • Straightforward use and clean-up
  • Heats up easily
  • Lock handle for upright storage
Cons
  • Plates not detachable
  • No grease collector

5. Hamilton Beach 25490

Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast 25490

For a complete breakfast sandwich, the Hamilton Beach 25490 is your friend. It is made of several parts so you can add a layer of your choice: eggs, meat, cheese, and more. Perfect for a morning rush, it can accommodate two sandwiches at a time. You and your family can grab and go with a freshly made sandwich of your choice.

The 600-watt heating coils power the Hamilton Beach 25490. It is energy-efficient and can prepare sandwiches in five minutes. The indicator light turns on when the device is hot enough for use. It comes with a timer and beeps when finished.

The removable parts are dishwasher safe. Although it’s bulkier than the other sandwich makers in the list, clean-up is quick and does not require too much time and effort. The price is quite high, but it’s all worth it.

Pros
  • Comes with a timer and beep
  • Cooks sandwiches in five minutes
  • 600-watt energy efficiency
  • Allows you to add sandwich layers of your choice
Cons
  • More expensive than the other products in the list
  • Requires assembly

6. Kealive ST68A

Kealive Sandwich Maker

For features similar to the Aicok Sandwich Maker, the Kealive Sandwich Maker is a more affordable option. It comes with three detachable non-stick grill plates for various meals such as meat, toasts, and waffles. Aside from the less expensive price, it requires less wattage and comes with a more extended warranty of three years.

The Kealive Sandwich Maker can prepare larger servings of sandwiches and waffles. In just three minutes, it reaches the required preset temperatures of 392 degrees before you can set up your lunch or pour in the batter.

It also features a cool-touch handle and a heat-proof exterior. The base is non-slip, so it stays in place while in use. After use, the anodized aluminum plates are detachable, and you can toss them in the dishwasher.

Pros
  • Can prepare larger sandwiches and waffles
  • Three detachable grill plates for more meal variety
  • Backed by a three-year warranty
  • Overheat protection features
  • Requires small storage space
Cons
  • Thin grill plates
  • Fixed hinge

What to Consider Before Buying a Sandwich Maker?

The best sandwich makers don’t have to be expensive. By identifying the different ways of how you can personalize your toast, you will know the features and mechanisms vital to you.

Do you plan to prepare sandwiches for the whole family? Then a sandwich maker that can accommodate multiple slices of bread is a reasonable consideration.

Do your kids love toast in the morning? Then a breakfast sandwich maker is suitable for your household.

Choosing a good sandwich maker should not be difficult. But beware of buying low-cost products that might give up after a few uses or doesn’t quickly heat the bread. For your guidance, here are a few essential factors to consider:

1. Main Purpose

For home-use, a medium sandwich/panini grill is perfect. They are intended for occasional use in various locations such as backyards, pool area, or kitchen. For reheating tortillas or meats, this size is just enough. Heavy-duty sandwich makers made of more substantial bodies and durable hinges withstand arduous use for commercial purposes.

2. Single or dual

Single size saves space and energy-efficient for preparing small servings of sandwiches. Dual grills are larger and can do tasks in one operation simultaneously.

3. Choose non-stick plates

Non-stick plates quickly release the toast. They are easy to wash, and you can even wipe off the mess. Beware though that Teflon coating can be dangerous to health when it reaches maximum temperature.

The Final Verdict

The best sandwich maker is more of a personal choice and preference. All of the products mentioned above have easy-to-clean nonstick plates and indicator lights. For most users, though, the Breville BSG520XL Panini Duo Press is the best choice. The reasons are simple: it is affordable, easy to use, and comes in adjustable hinges.

Leave a Comment